Traditional vs. Modern Birthstones: What You Need to Know

Traditional vs. Modern Birthstones: What You Need to Know

Birthstones have fascinated people for centuries, symbolizing the month of one’s birth and often holding deep personal or cultural significance. However, did you know that there are both traditional and modern birthstone lists? Each offers unique perspectives on these captivating gems. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between traditional and modern birthstones, their history, and how to choose the perfect stone for you or a loved one.


What Is the Difference Between Modern and Traditional Birthstones?

Traditional birthstones, also known as ancient birthstones, date back centuries and are rooted in cultural and religious beliefs. These stones often varied by region and were chosen based on their symbolism or believed mystical properties.

In contrast, modern birthstones are a standardized list created in 1912 by the National Association of Jewelers in the United States. The modern list was designed to provide consistency and adapt to the availability of gemstones, making it easier for jewelers and consumers.


The Original Birthstones

Traditional birthstones were not set in stone (pun intended). Different cultures and time periods had their own lists. For example:

  • January: Garnet, Hyacinth
  • February: Amethyst, Pearl
  • March: Bloodstone, Jasper
  • April: Diamond, Sapphire
  • May: Emerald, Agate
  • June: Pearl, Turquoise, Agate
  • July: Ruby, Onyx
  • August: Sardonyx, Moonstone
  • September: Chrysolite, Sardonyx
  • October: Opal, Aquamarine
  • November: Topaz, Pearl
  • December: Bloodstone, Ruby

These choices often reflected the gemstones available and valued in specific regions.


The Modern Birthstone List

The modern list, created in the 20th century, streamlined and updated birthstone assignments. Some months now have multiple options to cater to taste and budget. Here’s the modern list:

Notably, changes continue to occur. For example, in 2016, spinel was added as an alternative birthstone for August.


What Is the Real Birthstone of December?

December has one of the most varied birthstone assignments. Traditionally, December’s birthstones included bloodstone and ruby. Today, the modern list offers turquoise, zircon, and tanzanite as options. This variety allows December babies to choose from striking blues and vibrant reds, catering to different tastes and budgets.


Why Have Birthstones Changed?

Birthstones evolved over time for several reasons:

  1. Cultural Influences: Different regions and beliefs shaped traditional lists.
  2. Gemstone Availability: Some traditional stones became scarce or prohibitively expensive. Modern alternatives ensured affordability.
  3. Standardization: Jewelers aimed to create a uniform system, simplifying selection for customers.
  4. Fashion Trends: New gemstones were introduced to reflect changing tastes and preferences.

Choosing the Perfect Birthstone

Whether you’re drawn to traditional or modern birthstones, there are no hard rules when selecting one. Here are some tips:

  1. Embrace Alternative Stones: If your birthstone doesn’t resonate with you, consider zodiac or cultural alternatives. For example, someone born in April might choose sapphire instead of diamond.
  2. Explore Affordable Lookalikes: If cost is a concern, look for similar gems like moissanite (for diamonds) or white topaz.
  3. Combine Gemstones: Personalize jewelry by blending birthstones with other meaningful stones.
  4. Learn the History: Understanding a stone’s symbolism can deepen your connection to it.

FAQs

What are the original birthstones?
The original birthstones varied by culture and often included gems like garnet, amethyst, and sapphire, reflecting local availability and beliefs.

What is the real birthstone of December?
December’s traditional stones include bloodstone and ruby, while modern lists feature turquoise, zircon, and tanzanite.

Why have birthstones changed?
Changes were driven by cultural influences, availability, standardization, and fashion trends, ensuring birthstones remained accessible and appealing.

Can I choose a different birthstone?
Absolutely! Birthstones are a guideline, not a rule. Choose the gem that resonates with you or matches your style.


Birthstones, whether traditional or modern, offer a beautiful way to celebrate one’s identity and heritage. By understanding their history and symbolism, you can find a gemstone that truly speaks to you.

Explore other birthstones

Discover our gemstone jewellery now!

Back to blog